Why genuine negotiation is key in a collective dismissal? When a collective dismissal in Spain is declared void, the problem is not always that the company lacked legitimate grounds for restructuring. In many cases, the dispute concerns how the consultation period was conducted: the decision appeared to have been made before negotiations began, relevant information was not provided, representatives’ proposals were left unanswered, or there was no genuine room for negotiation.
The consequences can be particularly serious. A finding that a collective dismissal is void may require the company to reinstate the affected employees and pay the corresponding back pay.
The consultation period should therefore not be treated as a formal step that the company simply needs to complete. There must be genuine, good-faith negotiation, supported by sufficient information and a real opportunity to discuss alternatives to the dismissals and measures to mitigate their consequences.
At Suárez de Vivero, we advise national and international companies on the preparation and negotiation of collective dismissal procedures, particularly where international structures, group restructurings or multiple workplaces are involved.
What does Spanish law require during the consultation period?
Article 51.2 of the Spanish Workers’ Statute provides that the consultation period must address, at a minimum, three issues:
- the possibility of avoiding or reducing the dismissals;
- measures to mitigate their consequences, such as outplacement, training and professional retraining;
- and the grounds relied upon by the company to justify the collective dismissal.
The parties must negotiate in good faith and with a view to reaching an agreement.
This does not mean that the company is legally required to reach an agreement. The procedure may end without an agreement and the company may maintain its decision, provided that it has properly complied with its obligations throughout the consultation period.
The distinction is important: the obligation is to negotiate in good faith, not to guarantee a particular outcome.
The Spanish Labour Procedure Act provides for the nullity of a collective dismissal, among other circumstances, where the consultation period was not conducted, the required documentation was not provided, the decision was adopted through fraud, deceit, coercion or abuse of rights, or fundamental rights were violated.
Spanish Supreme Court case law has recognised that bad-faith negotiation may lead to nullity where the circumstances justify such a consequence.
What may courts consider bad-faith negotiation?
There is no single action that automatically means that a company has negotiated in bad faith. Courts assess the procedure as a whole.
However, certain practices can significantly weaken the company’s position.
The decision had already been made before consultation began
One of the main risks arises when the company communicates or implements the decision before genuine negotiations have started.
This may occur, for example, where the company makes a global announcement, presents the restructuring to investors, hires replacement employees or transfers functions to another country before opening the consultation period.
The existence of definitive lists of affected employees circulating internally before representatives have had an opportunity to negotiate may also be problematic.
The issue is not that the company has an initial proposal. It is entirely legitimate for the company to arrive at the negotiating table with a defined position.
The problem arises when that position is completely non-negotiable from the outset and the consultation period becomes merely a formality.
Maintaining a completely fixed position
A company may begin the procedure with a specific proposal concerning the number of dismissals, selection criteria and financial terms.
However, there must be genuine room for negotiation.
If the company maintains exactly the same proposal throughout the entire consultation period, without making counteroffers or explaining why the alternatives proposed by the representatives are not viable, questions may arise regarding good-faith negotiation.
The courts may assess how the negotiation evolved rather than looking only at its final outcome.
Failing to provide relevant information
The company must provide the documentation necessary for employee representatives to negotiate on an informed basis.
Not every documentary omission automatically results in nullity.
The key question is whether the missing information was relevant and whether its absence prevented or significantly hindered an informed negotiation.
Late disclosure can also be problematic where there is no longer sufficient time for the representatives to analyse the information and formulate proposals during the consultation period.
Companies should therefore anticipate what additional information representatives are likely to request and have it prepared before negotiations begin.
Ignoring representatives’ proposals
Negotiation also requires the company to engage with the other side.
If employee representatives propose alternatives to reduce the number of dismissals, improve social measures or modify the selection criteria, the company should respond with reasons.
It does not necessarily have to accept those proposals.
However, systematically ignoring them or rejecting them without explaining why they are not viable may be used as evidence that the consultation was merely formal.
Negotiating directly with employees outside their representatives
Another risk arises when the company attempts to achieve individually what it is unable to achieve at the negotiating table.
For example, pressuring individual employees to accept an exit while the company is negotiating with their representatives may weaken the company’s position.
Negotiations should take place within the statutory framework and respect the role of employee representatives.
Negotiators must have genuine decision-making authority
This is particularly important for international groups.
If the people participating in negotiations do not have the authority to commit the company and must refer every issue back to headquarters, the time available for genuine negotiation may be significantly reduced.
The problem is not that the parent company is involved in the decision-making process. The problem arises when the negotiating team has no real authority to negotiate.
The consultation period is subject to strict time limits. International groups should therefore ensure that the people attending the negotiating table have clearly defined authority to negotiate within agreed parameters.
How should a company prepare the consultation period?
A strong negotiation begins well before the first meeting.
Start with an initial proposal but leave room to negotiate
The company should know its initial position: the number of affected employees, selection criteria, severance terms and accompanying measures.
However, it should also determine in advance how far it is prepared to move during the negotiations.
This makes it possible to structure concessions and avoid having every proposal depend on a new approval from the parent company.
The company can have a clear negotiation strategy without turning its initial position into an immovable one.
Have all documentation ready from the outset
The documentation required for the collective dismissal should be available from the beginning.
It is also advisable to prepare information that employee representatives are likely to request during the consultation period, including departmental data, costs, alternatives considered, business forecasts, organisational structures and possible alternative measures.
Providing information late can significantly reduce the time available for meaningful negotiation.
Ensure the negotiating team has sufficient authority
In international groups, the negotiating team should have prior authorisation to reach agreements within defined parameters.
Waiting for headquarters to approve every issue after each meeting can result in a procedure that progresses without genuine negotiation.
The company must be able to respond to representatives’ proposals within the statutory timetable.
Coordinate internal and external communications
What the company tells employees, clients, investors or the media must be consistent with what is being discussed during the consultation period.
A corporate presentation announcing the dismissals as a final decision while the company tells employee representatives that alternatives are still being considered can become particularly damaging evidence.
In international groups, corporate communications should therefore be coordinated with the Spanish procedure and its timetable.
How should the negotiation be documented?
The minutes of the consultation period are particularly important.
If the collective dismissal is subsequently challenged, the courts may reconstruct the negotiation based on the meeting minutes, documents provided and communications exchanged during the procedure.
The minutes should accurately reflect what happened
The minutes should record, with sufficient detail, the proposals made by each party, the responses provided and the information exchanged.
The objective is not to create unnecessarily lengthy documents, but to establish a clear record of how the negotiation developed.
Respond in writing to relevant proposals
Where representatives make an alternative proposal or request relevant information, the company should provide a reasoned response.
A negative response may be entirely legitimate.
What matters is that there is an explanation showing why the proposal is not viable or why the requested information cannot be provided in the terms requested.
There should be genuine movement during the negotiation
The evolution of the negotiations can be particularly important.
Measures that may demonstrate a genuine negotiation include reducing the number of affected employees, improving financial terms, opening a voluntary departure period or expanding outplacement measures.
The company is not required to accept every proposal made by employee representatives.
What must be demonstrated is that there was a genuine possibility of modifying the initial proposal.
Social measures and outplacement
The consultation period must also address measures designed to mitigate the impact of the collective dismissal.
Where legally required, the company must prepare an external outplacement plan.
This should not be treated as a purely formal document. It should genuinely address the needs of the affected employees and form part of the social measures discussed during the negotiations.
Training, professional retraining, outplacement, voluntary departures and other measures may all form part of the company’s negotiation strategy.
What happens if an agreement is reached?
If the negotiations end with an agreement, the company’s position is significantly strengthened.
The agreement must be approved by the legally required majority of employee representatives and may subsequently limit the scope for judicial challenges concerning certain aspects of the collective dismissal.
However, an agreement does not automatically cure a procedure that was seriously defective.
The company must still have properly complied with its essential obligations during the consultation period, including providing the required documentation and negotiating in good faith.
Reaching an agreement does not therefore mean that the company can disregard the procedural safeguards established by law.
What happens if there is no agreement?
The absence of an agreement does not necessarily prevent the company from proceeding with the collective dismissal.
The company may maintain its decision and notify the employee representatives and the labour authority within the applicable legal deadline.
Under Royal Decree 1483/2012, the company must communicate its final decision within 15 days of the date of the last meeting held during the consultation period.
If the company fails to communicate its decision within the applicable deadline, the procedure may lapse and a new procedure may have to be initiated.
Where there is no agreement, it is particularly important that the final decision remains consistent with the negotiation that took place and reflects, where appropriate, improvements offered by the company during the consultation period.
The consultation process starts before the first meeting
One of the most common mistakes is to assume that the consultation process begins when the first meeting with employee representatives takes place.
In reality, many of the problems that later arise at the negotiating table are created much earlier.
A premature announcement, an individual exit that was not taken into account, a corporate timetable incompatible with Spanish deadlines or a decision already communicated to the parent company may all affect the procedure.
For this reason, Spanish employment counsel should be involved from the design stage of the restructuring, particularly where the decision is being made within an international group.
The Spanish procedure should be coordinated with the company’s wider restructuring strategy from the outset.
At Suárez de Vivero, we advise national and international companies on business restructuring in Spain, negotiations with employee representatives and employment litigation in Spain.
The key is not reaching an agreement, but genuinely negotiating
The consultation period does not require the company to accept the employees’ proposals or guarantee that the procedure will end in an agreement.
What it requires is something different: genuine, informed and good-faith negotiation.
For the company, this means arriving prepared, providing the necessary documentation, listening to alternatives, responding to proposals, allowing the position to evolve during the negotiations and properly documenting the entire process.
If the procedure subsequently reaches the courts, it will not be enough to explain why the company needed to restructure. It must also be able to demonstrate how it negotiated that decision.
Properly preparing the consultation period is therefore one of the most effective ways to reduce the risk of a collective dismissal being declared void.
Frequently Asked Questions About the Consultation Period in a Collective Dismissal
Is the company required to reach an agreement?
No. The company must negotiate in good faith and with a view to reaching an agreement, but it may maintain its decision if the parties do not reach an agreement.
What constitutes bad faith during the consultation period?
Conduct that may create problems includes implementing or announcing the decision before negotiations begin, maintaining a completely fixed position, refusing to provide relevant information, failing to respond to representatives’ proposals or negotiating directly with employees outside their representatives.
Does any failure to provide documentation make a collective dismissal void?
No. The key issue is whether the missing information was relevant and whether its absence prevented the representatives from negotiating on an informed basis.
What happens if there is no agreement during the consultation period?
The company may communicate its final decision within the applicable legal deadline. The absence of an agreement does not, by itself, prevent the company from proceeding with the collective dismissal.
Why are the minutes of the consultation period so important?
Because they provide evidence of how the negotiation developed. If the collective dismissal is challenged, the minutes can be one of the main sources of evidence regarding the proposals made, the company’s responses and the evolution of the negotiations.
Can the company modify its proposal during the consultation period?
Yes. In fact, genuine movement during the negotiations may help demonstrate that the consultation period was real. The company may modify the number of affected employees, financial terms or social measures within the parameters established by its strategy.
Can the parent company decide the terms of the negotiations in an international group?
The parent company may participate in the decision-making process, but the Spanish company should ensure that its negotiating team has sufficient authority to negotiate within the procedure and the deadlines established under Spanish law.