What companies should review before communicating an executive’s departure. An executive departure is a decision that requires careful preparation. The issue is not limited to the severance payment that may be due. An executive exit may also involve notice periods, bonuses, long-term incentives, shares, non-compete agreements and other contractual arrangements that can significantly affect the company’s final cost.
Before communicating the decision, the company must also determine which legal regime applies. The executive may be subject to the special senior management employment regime, an ordinary employment relationship or, in certain cases, a corporate relationship with the company as a director or board member.
An executive departure in Spain should therefore be approached as an employment, contractual and strategic process, rather than simply as the preparation of a termination letter.
Confirm the executive’s legal status
The first question the company should answer is what legal relationship it actually has with the executive.
If the executive qualifies as senior management, the Royal Decree 1382/1985 of 1 August regulating the special employment relationship of senior management personnel applies, with specific rules concerning termination, notice and severance.
If the executive has an ordinary employment relationship, the Spanish Workers’ Statute and the applicable collective bargaining agreement will apply.
The company should also check whether the executive was promoted internally from an ordinary employment position. In such cases, an ordinary employment relationship may have been suspended during the period of senior management, with potential consequences when the special relationship ends.
The legal classification should therefore be confirmed before deciding how to terminate the relationship, particularly where the executive works for a Spanish subsidiary of an international group.
Calculate the real cost of the exit
One of the most common mistakes is to calculate only the severance payment.
The actual cost may include:
- statutory or contractual severance;
- salary corresponding to the notice period;
- accrued bonuses;
- the proportional part of certain incentives;
- outstanding holiday entitlement;
- benefits in kind;
- shares, RSUs, options or phantom shares;
- long-term incentives;
- compensation associated with post-contractual non-compete agreements.
In international groups, a significant part of the executive’s remuneration may also be governed by parent-company plans rather than by the Spanish employment contract.
Before beginning negotiations, the company should therefore prepare a complete exit cost calculation, distinguishing between amounts that are actually payable and those that depend on the terms of individual incentive plans.
Review bonuses, shares and long-term incentives
Incentive plans are often one of the most complex aspects of an executive departure.
It is not enough to check the amount of the bonus appearing on the payroll. The relevant plan should be reviewed to determine:
- which objectives have already been achieved;
- which incentives have accrued;
- which amounts remain unpaid;
- which shares have already vested;
- which awards remain subject to vesting;
- how the plan treats a good leaver or bad leaver; and
- what happens when the company initiates the departure.
The accrual date and payment date are not necessarily the same. A clause requiring the executive to remain employed until a particular date should therefore be analysed carefully.
Where the plan is international, the law governing the plan should also be reviewed.
Review the post-contractual non-compete agreement
A post-contractual non-compete can represent a significant part of the cost of an executive departure.
For senior executives, Article 8.3 of Royal Decree 1382/1985 allows a post-contractual non-compete agreement of up to two years, provided that the company has a genuine industrial or commercial interest and appropriate financial compensation is provided.
The company should decide before termination whether it actually needs to maintain the restriction.
It should also review the specific terms of the covenant to determine whether and when it can waive it. Leaving this issue unresolved can create an unexpected financial obligation that was not included in the initial exit calculation.
Check whether the departure forms part of a restructuring
An executive departure should not be analysed in isolation where the company is restructuring its organisation.
If other employer-initiated terminations take place within a 90-day period, their potential impact on the collective dismissal thresholds under Article 51 of the Spanish Workers’ Statute should be assessed.
An apparently individual departure may therefore form part of a broader employment restructuring.
Before communicating the decision, the company should review which other positions will disappear, what organisational changes are planned and how responsibilities will be redistributed after the executive leaves.
Do not remove the executive’s responsibilities before communicating the departure
Another common mistake is to effectively implement the departure before formally communicating it.
Removing responsibilities, team members, information or decision-making powers may weaken the company’s position and create grounds for a claim by the executive.
The strategy should therefore be prepared before taking measures that materially alter the conditions under which the executive performs their role.
The company should avoid creating a situation in the days preceding the formal communication that contradicts the reasons subsequently set out in the exit documentation.
Choose the appropriate termination route
The appropriate route will depend on the applicable legal regime and the specific circumstances.
For senior management, different alternatives may be available, including employer withdrawal, disciplinary dismissal or a negotiated exit. For ordinary employees, the termination routes established under the Workers’ Statute must be considered.
The decision should not be based solely on cost.
The company should also consider whether there is a valid legal basis, what evidence is available, the risk of challenge, the executive’s circumstances, outstanding financial rights and the company’s objectives.
Employer withdrawal in senior management
Where the executive is subject to the special senior management employment regime, the company may terminate the relationship through employer withdrawal under the terms established by Royal Decree 1382/1985.
In the absence of a different contractual arrangement, Article 11 provides for compensation of seven days’ cash salary per year of service, subject to a maximum of six months’ salary.
The contract may establish more favourable terms for the executive and should therefore always be reviewed before termination is communicated.
Disciplinary dismissal
Disciplinary dismissal requires a serious and culpable breach and must be properly documented.
Using this route where the actual reason for the departure is a business restructuring may significantly increase the risk of a dispute.
The company should ensure that it has sufficient evidence to establish the facts relied upon as grounds for termination.
Negotiated exit
In practice, many executive departures are ultimately resolved through a settlement agreement.
This allows the parties to establish the departure date and jointly regulate severance, notice, bonuses, incentives, non-compete obligations, confidentiality and internal and external communications.
For the company, a negotiated exit can provide greater certainty regarding the final cost and reduce the risk of subsequent litigation.
What should an executive exit agreement include?
A properly structured exit agreement should specify, at a minimum, the amounts to be paid and the payment schedule.
It should also address confidentiality obligations, the return of equipment and information, the treatment of any non-compete agreement and, where necessary, communications concerning the departure to employees, clients and third parties.
Where bonuses, shares or long-term incentives are involved, the agreement should expressly establish how they will be treated.
It may also include a release of certain claims, provided that it is drafted proportionately and takes into account rights that cannot legally be waived.
In certain cases, it may be appropriate to establish a period of garden leave, during which the executive remains employed but is released from the obligation to perform services during the notice period.
Tax treatment of an executive departure
The tax structure should be analysed before the negotiation is finalised.
Article 7.e) of the Spanish Personal Income Tax Law provides for an exemption for certain dismissal or termination compensation up to the amount legally required, subject to a general limit of €180,000.
For senior management, Spanish case law has recognised the tax relevance of the mandatory minimum compensation applicable to employer withdrawal.
However, not every amount included in an exit package has the nature of compensation.
Notice pay, bonuses, outstanding holiday and other salary-related amounts are subject to a different tax treatment and should be correctly identified in the agreement.
Where a “net” amount is negotiated, it is particularly important to specify exactly which concepts it covers.
Executives who were promoted internally
The departure of an executive who previously held an ordinary employment position requires specific analysis.
Article 9 of Royal Decree 1382/1985 regulates certain internal promotion situations and may allow the ordinary employment relationship to resume when the special senior management relationship ends.
Before finalising the departure, the company should review the previous employment contract, the senior management agreement, recognised seniority and any agreement signed when the executive was promoted.
This analysis may significantly change the exit strategy.
Common mistakes in executive departures
One of the most common mistakes in international groups is using a parent-company template and translating it into Spanish without adapting its provisions to Spanish employment law.
It is also common to overlook contractual notice periods, calculate them only on base salary or fail to consider benefits in kind.
Another problem arises when the company alleges underperformance when the real reason for the departure is an organisational restructuring. If the available documentation does not support the stated reason, the company’s position may be significantly weakened.
Finally, issues such as non-compete obligations, bonuses and share plans should not be left until the last stage of the process.
Executive departure checklist
Before communicating an executive departure, the company should check:
- which legal regime applies;
- what the contract says about termination, notice and severance;
- whether there is a previous ordinary employment relationship;
- which bonuses and incentives have accrued;
- what happens to shares and long-term incentive plans;
- whether the non-compete agreement should remain in force;
- whether other terminations are connected to a restructuring;
- the tax treatment of each component;
- what documentation needs to be signed; and
- how the departure will be communicated.
A well-prepared exit reduces litigation risk
An executive departure should not be improvised.
Proper preparation allows the company to understand the real cost, select the appropriate termination route, negotiate from a stronger position and document the terms of the departure consistently.
By contrast, a poorly prepared exit may result in claims relating to severance, bonuses, shares, non-compete obligations or even the validity of the termination itself.
At Suárez de Vivero, we advise national and international companies on Senior Management and Executive Remuneration in Spain, including executive contracts, incentives, non-compete agreements and executive departures.
We also advise companies on employment litigation in Spain where an executive departure gives rise to a claim or judicial proceedings.
Frequently Asked Questions About Executive Departures in Spain
What should a company review before an executive departure?
The company should review the applicable legal regime, the contract, notice requirements, severance, bonuses, share plans, non-compete obligations and any previous employment relationship.
Can an executive departure be negotiated?
Yes. A settlement agreement can regulate the departure date, financial amounts, bonuses, incentives, confidentiality, non-compete obligations and other terms of the exit.
What severance is payable to a senior executive?
It depends on the termination route and the terms of the contract. In the case of employer withdrawal, in the absence of a different agreement, Royal Decree 1382/1985 provides for seven days’ cash salary per year of service, subject to a maximum of six months’ salary.
What happens to a bonus when an executive leaves?
The applicable incentive plan must be reviewed to determine when the bonus accrues, which objectives have been achieved and what conditions apply to payment following the executive’s departure.
What happens to shares or LTIPs when an executive leaves?
It depends on the applicable plan. The company should review vesting conditions, good leaver and bad leaver provisions and any change-of-control clauses.
Can a non-compete agreement remain in force after the executive leaves?
Yes, provided that the applicable legal and contractual requirements are met. For senior management, a post-contractual non-compete may last for up to two years.
What happens if the executive was promoted from an ordinary position?
The company should determine whether the ordinary employment relationship was suspended and what was agreed when the promotion took place. The end of the senior management relationship may allow the previous employment relationship to resume in certain circumstances.