The employment impact of an M&A transaction goes beyond due diligence. In mergers and acquisitions in Spain, employment matters are often associated with due diligence: reviewing employment contracts, identifying liabilities and assessing whether any risks should affect the purchase price.
But due diligence is only one part of the transaction.
Many of the most significant employment issues arise later: when employee representatives must be informed, during the period between signing and closing, when two workforces are integrated or when the acquisition is followed by a restructuring.
Employment planning should therefore begin at the early stages of the transaction and continue through closing and post-closing integration.
At Suárez de Vivero, we advise buyers, sellers and investment funds throughout the employment aspects of M&A transactions in Spain, from due diligence and SPA negotiations to workforce integration and post-acquisition restructuring.
The transaction structure determines the employment consequences
The first issue is to determine what type of transaction is taking place. A share deal does not have the same employment consequences as the acquisition of a business unit or a merger.
Share deal
In a share deal, the acquired company remains the employer. The change of shareholder does not, by itself, trigger a transfer of employment contracts or automatically activate the rules under Article 44 of the Spanish Workers’ Statute.
This does not mean that the transaction has no employment consequences.
Any subsequent integration of teams, harmonisation of employment terms, reorganisation or workforce reduction must still comply with the applicable Spanish employment rules.
Asset deal, carve-out or transfer of a business unit
Where an autonomous business unit is transferred, the transfer of undertaking rules under Article 44 of the Spanish Workers’ Statute may apply.
Article 44 of the Spanish Workers’ Statute provides for the transfer of the employment and Social Security rights and obligations relating to the affected employees.
The seller and buyer may also be jointly liable for three years for certain employment obligations arising before the transfer and remaining unpaid.
In a carve-out, one of the most important practical questions is determining which employees are actually assigned to the transferred business unit.
This can be particularly difficult where employees work across several areas, where there are shared services or where executives have cross-functional responsibilities.
This should be resolved before signing rather than when the transaction is about to close.
Mergers and demergers
Mergers and demergers may also constitute transfers of undertaking and must be analysed together with the applicable corporate law.
Royal Decree-Law 5/2023, which regulates certain structural changes of companies, also establishes information requirements concerning the consequences of the transaction for employment.
The employment dimension should therefore be integrated into the transaction structure from the outset rather than treated as a separate workstream.
Information and consultation with employee representatives
Where a transfer of undertaking takes place, the transaction may trigger specific information and consultation obligations.
Article 44 of the Workers’ Statute requires the seller and buyer to inform their employee representatives about matters including:
- the planned date of the transfer;
- the reasons for the transaction;
- its legal, economic and social consequences;
- the measures envisaged in relation to employees.
If either company plans to adopt employment measures as a result of the transfer, a consultation period may also be required.
The timing of these communications should be carefully coordinated with the transaction timetable and corporate announcements.
For international groups, any obligations towards a European Works Council or other transnational employee representative bodies should also be considered.
Allowing employees to learn about the transaction from the press before hearing from their representatives can unnecessarily damage employee relations at a particularly sensitive stage.
The period between signing and closing also creates employment risks
The period between signing and closing often receives less attention, even though important decisions may be taken during this period that the buyer will ultimately inherit.
The SPA should establish which employment decisions the seller may not take without the buyer’s prior consent.
These may include:
- hiring or dismissing employees above agreed thresholds;
- granting extraordinary salary increases;
- awarding exceptional bonuses;
- amending collective agreements or entering into agreements with employee representatives;
- agreeing executive departures;
- making significant changes to working conditions.
The objective is to prevent the target company from taking decisions between signing and closing that materially alter its employment profile.
Pre-closing dismissals
In some transactions, the seller may be asked to reduce the workforce before closing.
This can be legitimate where there are genuine grounds supporting the terminations.
The problem arises when dismissals are carried out to avoid the transfer of particular employees or artificially alter the scope of the transaction.
In those circumstances, courts may consider the dismissals fraudulent, potentially creating consequences for both the seller and the buyer.
The question of who restructures, when and on what grounds should therefore be addressed with employment counsel and not solely from the perspective of the SPA.
Transitional Services Agreements
Transitional Services Agreements (TSAs) are common where the seller continues providing certain services to the buyer after closing.
These arrangements must be carefully structured.
If employees formally remain employed by the seller but, in practice, work under the direction and organisation of the buyer, there may be a risk of unlawful supply of workers under Article 43 of the Spanish Workers’ Statute.
The separation between the responsibilities of each company should therefore be clear both contractually and in day-to-day operations.
Integrating two workforces without creating new disputes
Closing the transaction does not end the employment work. In many cases, it is when the most complex phase begins: workforce integration.
Which collective agreement applies?
In a transfer of undertaking, transferred employees generally retain their original collective agreement until it expires or another applicable agreement comes into force, subject to the rules established by law.
The acquisition therefore does not automatically mean that the buyer’s collective agreement applies to the transferred workforce.
Before implementing the integration, the company should review the applicable collective agreements, their functional and territorial scope and any existing agreements with employee representatives.
Harmonising employment terms
Individual employment rights and more favourable conditions do not automatically disappear as a result of an acquisition.
If the objective is to reduce certain terms so that they align with those of the acquiring company’s workforce, it may be necessary to reach an agreement or follow the procedure for a substantial modification of working conditions under Article 41 of the Workers’ Statute, where its requirements are met.
Upward harmonisation may be legally easier, but it still has a cost and may create knock-on effects for other employees.
Integration should therefore be planned before closing, particularly where the employment conditions of the two workforces differ significantly.
Two pay structures after the acquisition
Maintaining different remuneration systems for work of equal value may create equality and gender pay gap risks.
The development of pay transparency requirements makes it even more important to review how salaries, bonuses and allowances are structured across the two workforces.
It is generally preferable to plan a convergence strategy from the outset rather than allow differences to become entrenched.
Employee representation
The transaction may also affect employee representation.
If the transferred business unit retains its autonomy, employee representatives may retain their mandate.
If the structure is integrated into the acquiring company, the representation structure and employee consultation arrangements may need to be reorganised.
Executives and key employees: a strategic issue
In many transactions, the value of the acquisition depends significantly on retaining certain executives, technical specialists or commercial employees.
The employment strategy should therefore specifically review:
- change-of-control clauses;
- severance arrangements or golden parachutes;
- long-term incentives;
- vesting acceleration;
- retention bonuses;
- management equity;
- good leaver and bad leaver provisions;
- non-compete agreements;
- retention arrangements.
A change of control may trigger financial rights precisely when the acquisition takes place.
It is also important to ensure that these incentive arrangements are compatible with the executive’s Spanish employment relationship.
For more information on the legal classification of executives, see our article on when an executive is really senior management in Spain.
Where the transaction involves the departure of executives, companies should also consider the appropriate strategy for executive departures in Spain.
Post-acquisition restructuring should be planned before closing
If the investment case includes workforce synergies, cost reductions or the integration of departments, the restructuring should be planned before closing.
The company should not wait until the day after closing to start assessing the employment consequences.
Which grounds can justify the restructuring?
Synergies resulting from an integration may, depending on the circumstances, support organisational or production grounds.
Economic grounds, however, must be assessed in relation to the employing company. A target company in a positive financial position may have difficulties relying solely on losses incurred by another group company to justify an economic restructuring.
The grounds must be properly connected to the circumstances of the employing entity.
How are collective dismissal thresholds calculated?
If a workforce reduction is planned after an acquisition, the terminations carried out by the companies involved and the relevant 90-day period must be reviewed.
Terminations carried out before closing may be relevant when determining whether the statutory thresholds for a collective dismissal are subsequently reached.
The restructuring timetable should therefore be designed together with the overall transaction strategy.
For more information, see our articles on collective dismissal in Spain and the consultation period in a collective dismissal.
Coordinating the different procedures
The information and consultation process arising from the transfer of undertaking, any collective dismissal consultation period and the group’s corporate communications should all fit within a single timetable.
A transaction may involve several employment processes at the same time, and they cannot always be managed independently.
The risk of creating a pathological employment group
Integration can also create a risk that did not previously exist.
Where companies within the same group share employees indiscriminately, mix their assets, operate through a single cash pool or function in practice as a single employer, the courts may consider that a pathological employment group exists.
The consequences can be significant: the companies may become jointly liable for employment obligations, and the grounds for certain collective measures may be assessed across the group.
Maintaining genuine separation between the companies is therefore also part of proper employment integration.
Employment contracts, payroll, management structures, intercompany invoicing and the actual direction of employees should reflect the legal autonomy of each entity where that autonomy exists.
An M&A transaction requires an employment strategy from start to finish
The employment impact of a corporate transaction does not end with due diligence or the signing of the SPA.
An acquisition can trigger information and consultation obligations, create risks between signing and closing, raise difficulties when harmonising employment conditions, activate executive compensation rights and ultimately lead to a restructuring that must be planned under Spanish employment law.
Employment counsel should therefore be involved from the beginning.
At Suárez de Vivero, we advise companies, investment funds and international groups on labour due diligence in Spain, employment aspects of transaction documentation, information and consultation, workforce integration and business restructurings in Spain.
The advantage of integrating employment matters from the outset is that the company can address risks before they become problems: structure the transaction correctly, protect the buyer, plan the integration and anticipate any post-closing restructuring.
Frequently Asked Questions About Mergers and Acquisitions in Spain and Employment Law
Does a merger trigger a transfer of undertaking?
Yes. Mergers and demergers may constitute transfers of undertaking under Article 44 of the Spanish Workers’ Statute, resulting in the transfer of the relevant employment contracts and obligations.
Must employee representatives be informed of an acquisition?
Where a transfer of undertaking takes place, yes. The seller and buyer must provide information regarding the date, reasons, legal, economic and social consequences and planned measures. If employment measures are envisaged, a consultation period may also be required.
Can the seller dismiss employees before closing?
The seller may do so where there are genuine grounds supporting the terminations. However, dismissals intended to avoid the transfer of employment or artificially reduce the workforce may be considered fraudulent.
Can employment terms be harmonised after the acquisition?
Yes, but not automatically. Reducing certain employment terms may require an agreement or a substantial modification of working conditions under Article 41 of the Workers’ Statute.
What happens to the collective agreement after an acquisition?
In a transfer of undertaking, the original collective agreement generally continues to apply to the transferred employees under the rules established by Article 44 of the Workers’ Statute until it expires or another applicable agreement comes into force.
What is a pathological employment group?
It is a situation in which several formally separate companies operate in practice as a single employer, for example through shared employees, commingled assets or a single cash pool. This may result in joint liability for employment obligations.
What should be reviewed in executive contracts before an acquisition?
Companies should review change-of-control clauses, severance arrangements, bonuses, long-term incentives, management equity, non-compete agreements, retention arrangements and good leaver and bad leaver provisions.